Hey, remember this?
It’s the food guide pyramid! Do we use this anymore? Nope! Why not? I remember looking at the base, which was grains, and thinking, “I can mostly eat grains. Got it. Let’s do this!”. I think a lot of people felt that way. So throughout the course of the past several years, the USDA has developed a different food guide that demonstrates how better to balance your diet. It’s called….
MyPlate
Without even knowing anything else about it, you know this much: you better start eating more fruits and vegetables. I like that. The basic breakdown is ½ your plate should be fruits and vegetables, ¼ should be grains, ¼ should be protein. And a serving of dairy on the side.
Let’s take a closer look at the recommendations from each of the 5 food groups:
Fruit
-Any fruit, or 100% fruit juice (fresh, canned, frozen, dried)
-Recommended servings/ day for adults : 1 ½ - 2 cups
Vegetables
- Any vegetable, or 100% vegetable juice (raw, cooked, fresh, frozen, canned, or dried/ dehydrated)
-Recommended servings/ day for adults: 2-3 cups overall
-dark green: 1 ½- 2 cups/ week
-starchy: 4-6 cups/ week
-red and orange: 4-6 cups/ week
-beans and peas (legumes, also part of the protein group): 1-2 cups/ week
-other vegetables: 3 ½ - 5 cups/ week
Grains
-Whole- the entire grain kernel (bran, germ and endosperm). Ex.: whole wheat flour, bulgar/ cracked wheat, oatmeal, whole cornmeal, brown rice.
-Refined- milled, or processed, removing the bran and germ (for finer texture and longer shelf life), and therefore losing dietary fiber, iron and many B vitamins. Ex: white flour, de-germed cornmeal, white bread, white rice.
-Recommended servings/ day for adults: 5-8 oz
Protein
-Meat (lean/ low-fat), poultry (lean/ low-fat), seafood (at least 8 oz/ week is recommended for most adults excluding vegetarians and those who are allergic), beans and peas (also counts as a vegetable), eggs, processed soy products, nuts, seeds.
-Recommended servings/ day for adults: 5-6 ½ oz equivalents (1 oz = 7g protein, roughly)
Dairy
-Not on plate, milk (cow or soy), yogurt, cheese, milk-based desserts (um...)
-Recommended servings/ day for adults: 3 cups
*Oils
-Not on plate, from plants and fish, canola, corn, cottonseed, olive, safflower, soybean, sunflower, walnut, sesame, and some foods with naturally occurring oils such as nuts, olives, fish and avocados, mayonnaise, some salad dressings, soft margarine (with no transfat) and some solid fats (saturated fats) derived from plates such as coconut oil, palm oil and palm kernel oil. Solid fats (solid at room temperature) should make up a much small portion of this subgroup and usually come from animals. Includes butter, milk fat, beef fat, chicken fat, pork fat, stick margarine, shortening, partially hydrogenated oil.
-No recommendations given for daily amounts
What I like about it:
-Balance, balance, balance. How many times have you seen people at mealtimes with plates made up of ½ meat and ½ grains or starches like rice, pasta or potatoes (burger and fries, my friends)? And maybe 1 tablespoon of vegetables? MyPlate demonstrates how to achieve balance. For most this means scaling back on grains and making room for more vegetables and fruits.
-Protein: Most people don’t have to be forced to eat protein. In fact, many probably overdo it. Now this is a general guide. Specific protein needs can be calculated and personalized for each individual (that’s the type of stuff I do) based on age, weight, height, gender and activity level, not to mention health conditions. That said, you might be surprised to find that you don’t need as much protein at each meal as you probably thought you did- in general. For example, a piece of chicken breast or fish the size of a deck of cards is about 3 oz, which provides 21 g of protein. These big huge chicken breasts injected with hormones that you often see at the grocery store…. uh, not 3 oz. Try 6- 8 oz or more.
-The website. It’s full of interactive tools and charts and tables that you can use to find out how to tailor this and eat appropriate portion sizes for children age 2 and up, teenagers, and adults, both young and old, male and female. And much more- portion sizes, food lists in each group, etc.. Take a look at it. It’s very informative and useful.
What I don’t like about it:
-Dairy group: Not exactly necessary (I have a dairy sensitivity, so I have to skip it myself). Could be protein group too though that’s never mentioned. This is emphasized primarily for calcium and vitamin D content. Also, I don’t drink 8 oz of milk at breakfast, lunch and dinner (gag, I don’t love milk like that). Side note: desserts as a serving of dairy? Hmmm.
-Vegetable group: You’re telling me to eat more starchy vegetables than dark green? That’s silly, and the message it’s sending is that white potatoes are a better choice than spinach or kale. Disagree.
-Grains: Makes it seem as though including refined/ processed grains is totally just as fine as eating whole grains. I’m all about balance, but if you ask me, refined grains should be a treat like dessert and not be a regular staple of any healthy meal.
-Oils: Again, while I’m all about balance, I think they’re making a sneaky defence for saturated fats and cholesterol, like there’s a minimum requirement for optimal health. Also, this section is a little overloaded and unclear to me.
-No mention of water as a most-important beverage and daily necessity. Makes it look like you just need to drink milk for thirst.
-To me, this is meant to model lunch and dinner, not breakfast. And how about snacks?
-If you have diabetes, your plate should look more like this instead to ensure consistent and controlled carbohydrate intake at meals (more on this later):
Now, here’s another plate model I recently discovered. It follows a similar pattern as MyPlate, with some variation, some of which address qualms I had.
Healthy Eating Plate (Harvard School of Public Health and Harvard Medical School)
Vegetables- The more and the greater variety, the better. Excludes potatoes and french fries.
Fruits- Eat plenty of fruits of all colors.
Whole grains- Eat a variety of whole grains, limit refined grains. (Boom.)
Healthy proteins- Choose fish, poultry, beans, nuts, limit red meat and cheese, avoid bacon, cold cuts and other processed meats. (Good point, will cut down on sodium tremendously.)
Healthy oils (not on plate)- Use healthy oils (like olive and canola oils), for cooking, on salad, and at the table. Limit butter. Avoid transfat. (Nailed it.)
Water (not on plate)- Drink water, tea or coffee (ideally without sugar), limit milk/ dairy to 1-2 servings/ day, juice to 1 small glass/ day, avoid sugary drinks.
I like this overall message very much. If you visit the website you will see more of the reasons behind the recommendations. This is not USDA funded. They mention things the USDA will not be telling the general public any time soon (not all USDA collaborators are dietitians, and that’s all I’m gonna say about that for now). For example, limiting fruit juice and sugary beverages to cut down on risk for obesity and diabetes, and limiting dairy to 1-2 servings/ day to cut down on risk of certain cancers.
SO, this is a lot of information, I know. Just try to take note of the big picture: balance. And don’t sweat little details just yet. Don’t you worry, I’m going to break this down even further for you in future posts. Just marinate on this for now!
Thanks for reading, and for the tremendously positive feedback on my first entry, and the blog in general! I am so happy to share. Stay tuned for more…
Jessica